Were the Emmys Worse Compared to Academy awards?

Knowing from responses round the Internet, audiences and testers were a lot more happy with the Emmy Honours on Sunday evening compared to they were using the Oscars in Feb. "This Emmy broadcast gave some lovely recognition to individuals who truly deserved it, and Jane Lynch wasn't a poor host, either," authored America online TV critic Maureen Ryan. "Overall, what's often a three-hour slogfest went by relatively rapidly and mostly easily this time around around." Except for the In Memoriam segment, as Ryan highlights -- in addition to a whole couple of other things. Were the Emmys really much better than the newest edition from the Academy awards? Moviefone looks into ahead. Host As Ryan states, Jane Lynch would be a very game MC for that Emmy proceedings, even when she wasn't given lots of good material to utilize. Her best joke is at presenting the cast of 'Entourage': "A great deal individuals are very curious why I am a lesbian -- as well as gentleman, the cast of 'Entourage.'" Lolz. Obviously, if Lynch was motionless on stage for 3 hrs, she'd have still done a more satisfactory job than James Franco and Hathaway As Catwoman. Advantage: Emmys Pre-created bits The Emmys were packed with pre-recorded segments, particularly a dent sequence which was edited by Fox after Alec Baldwin designed a joke concerning the NewsCorp phone-tapping scandal. (Baldwin was changed within the recorded segment by Leonard Nimoy.) Lynch was active, and also the opener featured all of the stars out of your favorite series, it survived about 95 minutes. OK, it had been really only 10, but nonetheless: too lengthy! Meanwhile, Franco and Hathaway's Academy awards opener was their high-point. Advantage: Academy awards Those who win The 2011 Oscars were essentially a fait accompli: 'The King's Speech,' Colin Firth, Natalie Portman, Melissa Leo and Christian Bale were management for days, as well as their collective wins were met with mostly shrugs. The Emmys, however, were packed with surprises: Melissa McCarthy! Kyle Chandler! (KYLE CHANDLER!) 'Friday Evening Lights' for series writing! Sure, 'Modern Family,' 'Mad Men' and 'The Daily Show' counseled me assumed those who win, however the tone set by early upsets made the groups feel suspenseful. (Not 'Modern Family' that demonstrate would be a lock for the best Comedy Series before Julie Bowen won her Emmy for the best Supporting Actress.) Advantage: Emmys Show pacing Regardless of the overblown introduction and extended bits -- as well as the ill-advised EmmyTones, a potential career-killer singing group comprised of actual stars like Joel McHale, Zachary Levi, Cobie Smulders and Wilmer Valderrama -- the Emmys ended quickly after three hrs. The 2011 Academy awards? They most likely will go on. Note to Brett Ratner: attempt to result in the 2012 version as stream-lined because the Emmys even when the show isn't good, a minimum of it may be short. Advantage: Emmys In Memoriam Segments Throughout the 2011 Oscars, Celine Dion sang a stylish rendition of "Smile" over photos of deceased people from the Hollywood family. In the Emmys, the Canadian Tenors sang a protective cover from the Leonard Cohen-written song "Hallelujah" while dry-ice produced a smoke-y effect within the auditorium. It had been badly as that sounds. Advantage: Academy awards Champion: Inside a much closer race than you thought, the Emmys emerge victorious! Congratulations to any or all participants and those who win. Your move, Academy awards. Were the Emmys better or worse compared to Academy awards?Better!Worse!Election Photos: Mark J. Terrill/AP (Jane Lynch), Gabriel Bouys/AFP/Getty Imges (James Franco, Hathaway As Catwoman)